Mafia - Gotta Catch 'Em All

[bloedmonster]

 

[Gawain86]

The MAFIA already know who ALL the TOWNYS are.........
So what do you have to lose? They might target you? Well so what, at least we will figure out who they are

Remember the rules were, if you don't vote, we will lynch you. If you are a TOWNY then vote so that we dont lynch you. I think thats fair

Mafia know who we are sure, but they don't know who we suspect and who we think are innocent (and might not be).
The more I think about it, the more I think this exercise gives better information to the mafia than it does to us.

 

[Cookie]

I have no idea what the hell you are saying? I thought this was only game 2?

I have so many reasons to suspect you.

Like earlier when I was specifically sending a message to the town cop, you replied saying you had no idea what I was talking about. I wasn't talking to you, so why pretend to be the town cop 😑
Now the town cop is dead which means you are not the cop. So much suspicion

 

[Cookie]

Mafia know who we are sure, but they don't know who we suspect and who we think are innocent (and might not be).
The more I think about it, the more I think this exercise gives better information to the mafia than it does to us.

Really.... If you are a TOWNY you would want to see what your other TOWNYS think. So why are you resisting. So what if they get something out of it, we are dead in the water if we dont help each-other.

 

[Gawain86]

Really.... If you are a TOWNY you would want to see what your other TOWNYS think. So why are you resisting. So what if they get something out of it, we are dead in the water if we dont help each-other.

If I knew who the townies were then knowing what they think is helpful. The only ones who do know that are the mafia.

 

[Cookie]

If I knew who the townies were then knowing what they think is helpful. The only ones who do know that are the mafia.

Ok if you don't vote ill assume you dodgey and add your name for your own vote.

 

[Cookie]

So far we have the below list.

Shad.O has been inactive the whole day. I would assume he would be more active if he was MAFIA being a crucial time.

Shad 4
Gawain 4
HNO3 3
Cookie 3
Aah Nuu Bru 2
Nickslayer 1
Bloed 0

Did this help?

https://imgur.com/WvrVuhC

 

[Gawain86]

VOTE Shad. If he wins then at least the mafia don't but I am suspicous of him so...

 

[Gawain86]

Shad 4
Gawain 4
HNO3 3
Cookie 3
Aah Nuu Bru 2
Nickslayer 1
Bloed 0

A mafia looking at this data would add their vote to the highest non mafia person and get them lynched "Oh but it was a town decision!"


Cookie ignoring this point is suspicious as hell.

 

[AAAH NUUU BRU]

So far we have the below list.

Shad.O has been inactive the whoel day. I would assume he would be more active if he was MAFIA being a crucial time.

Shad 4
Gawain 4
HNO3 3
Cookie 3
Aah Nuu Bru 2
Nickslayer 1
Bloed 0

https://imgur.com/WvrVuhC

Gona laugh my ass off if bloed is a mafia at the end of all of this

 

[Cookie]

A mafia looking at this data would add their vote to the highest non mafia person and get them lynched "Oh but it was a town decision!"


Cookie ignoring this point is suspicious as hell.

It doesn't matter who the MAFIA vote for. Either way they are going to kill a TOWNY because they know who all the townys are. DO you see?

AND if someone VOTES to LYNCH bloed then they are obviously a MAFIA

 

[AAAH NUUU BRU]

#vote bloed






























Just joking #unvote bloed

 

[Gawain86]

It doesn't matter who the MAFIA vote for. Either way they are going to kill a TOWNY because they know who all the townys are. DO you see?

WE are going to kill someone before night, mafia would like that to be townie yes? Mafia will manipulate us to make that happen.

AND if someone VOTES to LYNCH bloed then they are obviously a MAFIA

Doesn't follow, a townie could have info on him explaining that vote.

More importantly, WHY would mafia vote for an unlikely lynch? Far better to vote for a townie the rest are already suspicious of.

 

[Cookie]

More importantly, WHY would mafia vote for an unlikely lynch? Far better to vote for a townie the rest are already suspicious of.

Yes, you could be onto something here.

But before the Suspicion vote we were all clueless, now we at least have some info to vote with

 

[AAAH NUUU BRU]

Yes, you could be onto something here.

But before the Suspicion vote we were all clueless, now we at least have some info to vote with

Its messed me up tho, i was happily going to vote for HN03 with shad next and didnt even consider gaw and now it looks like he is top of the suspect list with shad for everyone

 

[bloedmonster]

Are you ladies done?
@Gawain86 your arguments strongly suggest that you are townie. @Cookie, you too.
So as townies, can we agree on a lynch here or not?

 

[Gawain86]

Yes, you could be onto something here.

But before the Suspicion vote we were all clueless, now we at least have some info to vote with

What exactly do we have? Suspicions with no or little evidence. A mixture of townies who guess right, townies who guess wrong and mafia throwing shade.

 

[Cookie]

Its messed me up tho, i was happily going to vote for HN03 with shad next and didnt even consider gaw and now it looks like he is top of the suspect list with shad for everyone

So then vote for HNO3 then. The list was more of an informative exercise. We can all still vote for whoever we like.

Remember gawain was only at the bottom of everyones list, so they have suspicions but not enough to put him first.

 

[Gawain86]

Are you ladies done?
@Gawain86 your arguments strongly suggest that you are townie. @Cookie, you too.
So as townies, can we agree on a lynch here or not?

I don't trust cookie. But I also don't trust you.

I will stick with Shad for now.

 

[Cookie]

Are you ladies done?
@Gawain86 your arguments strongly suggest that you are townie. @Cookie, you too.
So as townies, can we agree on a lynch here or not?

Yes I agree, the 3 of us are the only ones actively trying to help the TOWNYS.

Im voting for either HNO3 or AAH NU BRU

 

[bloedmonster]

I don't trust cookie. But I also don't trust you.

I will stick with Shad for now.

Fair enough, you are welcome to your opinion as you and cookie have clearly argued about.
I just really hope my gut is 3rd time lucky with @Shad.O

 

[Cookie]

So far we have the below list.

Shad.O has been inactive the whole day. I would assume he would be more active if he was MAFIA being a crucial time.

Shad 4
Gawain 4
HNO3 3
Cookie 3
Aah Nuu Bru 2
Nickslayer 1
Bloed 0

Did this help?

https://imgur.com/WvrVuhC

@Shad.O Have you caught up yet?

Care to tell us your suspicions ?

 

[HNO3ZA]

#Vote @Cookie

You have strong feelings about me, my names primarily comes up with your intentions over me, I dont have any trust in you at this point. My Mew sense is tingling. I have been doing nothing wrong in my own opinion. This might differ with everyone here. Lets hope that the true culprit (serial killer) and mafia can be eradicated... Mew out!

 

[Flex]

|Vote Count |

|---|---|

|Hno3|0|

|Cookie|1|

|Nicks|0|

|Alc|0|

|Aaah|0|

|Bloed|0|

|Gawain|0|

|Shad O|1|

_5 Votes needed to Lynch_

 

[bloedmonster]

I don't trust cookie. But I also don't trust you.

I will stick with Shad for now.

You need to #VOTE and then tag the person for it to be acknowledged by the all mighty mod

 

[bloedmonster]

Is no one seeing that @Shad.O is coming here, sniffing and leaving without a word?

 

[HNO3ZA]

Is no one seeing that @Shad.O is coming here, sniffing and leaving without a word?

I am yes, but he is not aggressive towards me in specific for no reason, as of yet, I have no proof other than absence from his side, that does remain suspicious....

 

[Cookie]

I have had a list form the beginning that I have been assigning roles to people and it has been changing throughout the game. The 2 names I listed are the only 2 roles I haven't had a reason to change from the beginning so I am going to stick to them and hope my gut instinct is right. After all everyone is very confused at the end here so Id rather use older data to vote than new data where everyone is scrambling to defend themselves.

HNO3 Im still not 100% convinced yet so I'm voting for,

#VOTE @AAAH NUUU BRU

 

[Gawain86]

#VOTE @Shad.O

 

[Cookie]

Is no one seeing that @Shad.O is coming here, sniffing and leaving without a word?

Yes I see as well. But as I said if he is jester and we lynch him, he wins. GG

Im not taking that risk, maybe the vigilante will kill him off while he sleeps 👏 no pressure